
American Horror Story: Asylum is the second installment of the hit anthology series, bringing psychological torture, alien abductions, and depravity to our television screens. The season takes place in Briarcliff Manor, an asylum so hellish that even the devil himself felt at home within its walls. While Briarcliff is fictional, it draws inspiration from infamous institutions in American history. Let’s take a deep dive into the real-life asylums and sanatoriums that inspired Asylum’s twisted setting.
Briarcliff Manor
Asylum opens with horny honeymooners Teresa and Leo Morrison exploring the most haunted places in America. The last stop on their morbid tour is the abandoned, decrepit Briarcliff Manor, originally built in 1908 as a tuberculosis hospital in Massachusetts. According to the newlyweds, an estimated 26,000 people died in the facility, with staff removing the bodies through an underground tunnel known as the death chute. Once the hospital closed in 1962, the Catholic Church took over and converted it into an asylum for the criminally insane.
The events of Asylum primarily take place in 1964, with Monsignor Timothy Howard and Sister Jude at the helm of this hellscape. Sister Jude is a strict disciplinarian who inflicts both corporal punishment and psychological torture on her patients. We’re talking ass beatings with canes, straitjackets, electroshock therapy, isolation, and forced sterilizations.
If you think Sister Jude is a bad seed, Dr. Arthur Arden is even worse. As the physician in charge of the medical unit, he conducts barbaric experiments on patients, turning them into subhuman creatures that roam the woods outside the manor. It’s no surprise that his workspace looks more like an old-school operating theater than a hospital ward.1
Since Arden was a doctor at the former tuberculosis hospital, he’s intimately familiar with the death chute and uses tuberculosis mixed with syphilis to create his monstrous mutants. He’s also a freaking Nazi à la Josef Mengele, the Angel of Death who conducted brutal experiments on prisoners in concentration camps. For more on Dr. Arden and Josef Mengele’s medical barbarity, see the upcoming post The Historical Figures That Inspired American Horror Story: Asylum.
The Death of Briarcliff
Asylum ends with Briarcliff Manor’s downfall. In the early 1970s, investigative journalist Lana Winters brings a film crew into the institution to film an exposé. Her motivations are twofold: she had a brief but horrific stint as a Briarcliff patient in 1964 thanks to Sister Jude’s manipulations, and she was attempting to free that same Sister Jude, who had become an inmate herself.
When things went to hell in a handbasket, the Catholic Church bounced, selling Briarcliff to the State of Massachusetts in 1965. Somehow, things got much worse. Conditions deteriorated, with rampant disease, death, and filth consuming the asylum. Lana’s exposé successfully shut down Briarcliff, resulting in a happy ending (kind of).
Real Asylums and Sanatoriums
Asylum’s Briarcliff Manor is a fictional facility, but there were plenty of real, equally fucked-up institutions in the United States. Let’s take a look at several asylums and sanatoriums that likely inspired American Horror Story.
Willowbrook State School
The Willowbrook State School in Staten Island, New York, was established in 1947 to treat mental disabilities. Despite this lofty goal, the conditions were appalling, and residents lived in filth. The school was so bad that when Senator Robert F. Kennedy visited Willowbrook in 1965, he called it a “snake pit” and called for a major overhaul.2 Despite Kennedy’s public denouncement, nothing was done. Zero, zip, zilch, nada.
In 1972, reporter Geraldo Rivera filmed Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace, a WABC-TV exposé. At the time, 5,300 patients were living at Willowbrook in unsanitary conditions. Due to massive budget cuts, the school had only 1 attendant for every 50 severely disabled children. As a result, patients were basically left to their own devices. Geraldo showed viewers this harsh reality, revealing naked kids lying on the floor, covered in their own feces.
According to Dr. Michael Wilkins, who had just been fired from the school, every patient contracted hepatitis within six months of admission. In addition to the physical horrors, there was virtually no programming or classes for them, just endless hours of nothing.
The exposé also revealed the conditions at the Letchworth Village Rehabilitation Center in Rockland County, New York. In a brilliant move, Geraldo and his crew arrived two hours early to catch the institution off guard. Congressman Mario Biaggi toured Letchworth with them and described it as worse than a military brig and most penal institutions. In disbelief, he said these were the “worst possible conditions I’ve seen in my life.”3
Impact of the Willowbrook Exposé
Lana Winters’ Briarcliff exposé in Asylum undoubtedly draws inspiration from Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace. She calls Briarcliff a “snake pit,” referencing the exact words RFK used to describe Willowbrook. She shows the same horrific conditions as Geraldo, claiming she wants to incite moral outrage. This was the real effect of the Willowbrook exposé, resulting in lasting change in the treatment of people with disabilities.
In the immediate aftermath, New York Governor Nelson Rockefeller restored 20 million dollars he had previously cut from the budget. These funds allowed Willowbrook and Letchworth to hire more employees and attendants. Despite the additional funding, patients’ families were fed up. They filed a class-action lawsuit, leading to a consent decree ordering Willowbrook to treat its patients humanely and provide educational programming.
The decree also addressed overcrowding, ordering Willowbrook to transfer residents to community-based housing. With the onset of community-based services, day programs, and adequate training for workers, the treatment of people with disabilities drastically improved in New York. Willowbrook finally closed its doors in 1987.4
Bedlam: Philadelphia’s Byberry and Cleveland State Hospital
Before Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace was Alfred Maisel’s “Bedlam 1946.” This exposé in Life magazine went after every shitty state-run mental institution in the United States. The article included scathing stories, a plethora of evidence, eyewitness accounts, and photographs that looked like they were from Nazi concentration camps. It was absolutely brutal in its takedown, citing horrific conditions like overcrowding, filth, starvation, physical abuse, medical abuse, incompetence, neglect, and staffing shortages. One governor even admitted, ” Our cows in the hospital barns get better care than the men and women in the wards.”5 Bruh.
Shockingly, Life published this exposé on May 6, 1946, but as we’ve learned, atrocious conditions in mental institutions persisted through the 1970s and 1980s.
Asylums in 1940s America
Maisel describes much of what Geraldo Rivera showed us through film: men, women, and children crowded in filthy wards, naked, sitting in feces. The photographs reveal patients locked in restraints, such as handcuffs, straitjackets, and sheets. If attendants didn’t restrain patients with physical implements, they threw them in solitary to suffer endlessly.
Patients were also chemically restrained in many institutions. Untrained attendants drugged these poor souls, leading to overdoses and death. Physicians were no better and were often incompetent, careless, or raging alcoholics. The few good ones were underpaid and overworked. There was also a dearth of nurses and attendants thanks to “legislative penny-pinching.”6 As a result, instead of implementing treatment plans and therapy, these facilities became mere custodians of the mentally ill.
Unfortunately, physical abuse was rampant in asylums. Maisel cites cases of attendants assaulting and even murdering patients in Missouri, Nebraska, Connecticut, and Ohio. While some of these incidents were reported, many were covered up and forgotten.
Although the exposé discusses several institutions across the country, it gives special attention to Byberry in Philadelphia. This hell on earth had a basement ward known as the “dungeon,” where a patient named George was murdered in 1937. Additionally, readers see heart-wrenching photographs of Byberry patients naked, in despair, and sleeping in overcrowded rooms.
As with the Willowbrook exposé, “Bedlam 1946” directly inspired American Horror Story: Asylum. We know this because Wendy—Lana Winters’ girlfriend—directly references it. Right before Sr. Jude’s machinations send Lana to Briarcliff, she talks about wanting a great story to write about, a Pulitzer Prize-winning story. That’s when Wendy mentions Maisel’s “Bedlam” as an example.
1940s Asylums Reform Movement
“Bedlam 1946” wasn’t all dire, though. It called for major reform and looked at Cleveland State Hospital as a shining example. Like other state-run institutions, Cleveland State was an abyss of despair comparable to the deepest circles in Dante’s Inferno. However, in 1943, several attendants grew a conscience and exposed the conditions to two prominent Cleveland citizens. With their help, a series of painstaking reforms culminated in vastly improved treatment for the mentally disabled in Ohio.
Danvers State Hospital

Since Briarcliff Manor is an institution from 1960s Massachusetts, let’s examine a real asylum on the East Coast. Danvers State Hospital, originally called the State Lunatic Hospital at Danvers, opened its doors on May 1, 1878. The State of Massachusetts built Danvers State to alleviate overcrowding in its three existing asylums. In a classic example of the road to hell is paved with good intentions, the asylum was originally meant to cure patients with educational programming and modern medicine. Administrators always intended it as a “temporary” stop for patients, who would return home once they made significant progress.
Danvers State was built according to the “Kirkbride Plan,” a model developed by Dr. Thomas Story Kirkbride. This centralized plan consisted of a main administration building with wings stretching out like a bat. The structure facilitated holistic healing with large treatment wards, fresh air, and gardens.
Over time, Danvers State descended into a nightmare. Overcrowding resulted in expansions, forcing the institution to abandon the Kirkbride Plan. Along with the population increase came budget cuts and severe neglect. As with other mental health hospitals, patient abuse was the order of the day. Patients were subjected to controversial treatments, including electroshock therapy and lobotomies. In fact, Walter Freeman—the physician who perfected the prefrontal lobotomy—did hundreds of these procedures at Danvers State Hospital. As a result, it earned the moniker, “the Birthplace of the Lobotomy.”7
Danvers State Hospital was in business until June 24, 1992. It was such a force in the American psyche that it inspired H.P. Lovecraft’s Arkham Sanitarium, which in turn inspired DC Comics’ Arkham Asylum in Batman. Famous residents include the Joker, Bane, Harley Quinn, and Scarecrow.
Waverly Hills Sanatorium
Before Briarcliff Manor was an asylum for the criminally insane, it was a tuberculosis hospital like the Waverly Hills Sanatorium in Louisville, Kentucky. Tuberculosis—also known as TB, the White Plague, and consumption—is a bacterial infection that can occur anywhere in the body but usually infects the lungs. Think of the old-timey movies you’ve seen, when someone coughs into a handkerchief and specks of blood appear. Everyone who sees the blood is aghast because they know that person is going to die, like, really soon. That’s tuberculosis.
Back in the day, there were many tuberculosis outbreaks. Unfortunately, there was no cure, and treatment consisted of rest, nutritious food, and fresh air. Since a bacterium causes tuberculosis, these treatments had limited effects, and patients often died.
To see how sanatoriums treated tuberculosis in 1936, watch the film On the Firing Line, by The National Tuberculosis Association.
Tuberculosis Sanatoriums
Tuberculosis hospitals began popping up all over the United States to treat those infected by the disease. These facilities, like Waverly Hills, were often in the countryside and were “self-contained” communities. The latter was very important because tuberculosis is highly contagious.
Thanks to Dr. Selman Waksman’s discovery of the antibiotic streptomycin in 1943, tuberculosis is now curable and no longer an epidemic in the United States. As a result of the cure, there was no longer a need for TB hospitals, and most closed up shop. Waverly Hills, for example, opened in 1910 and closed in 1961.
According to Mark Worthington, American Horror Story’s production designer, creator Ryan Murphy specifically wanted Briarcliff Manor’s origin story to be a tuberculosis hospital from the early 1900s. He knew that once the antibiotic cure was discovered, these large facilities were often repurposed. In Briarcliff’s case, it became a mental institution for the criminally insane.8
Designing Briarcliff
To design Briarcliff, Worthington and his team conducted extensive research on tuberculosis hospitals and asylums for inspiration. They learned, however, that TB hospitals were light and airy due to standard treatment methods. They wanted Briarcliff to be dark and creepy, so they designed their interior sets to mimic Maurits Cornelis Escher’s style. Escher was a Dutch graphic artist (1898–1972) who created claustrophobic, dizzying spaces in his artworks.9 Therefore, Briarcliff Manor’s dark rooms and long barrel-vaulted hallways are imaginative and not reflective of true historic interiors.
As with the interiors, Asylum creators wanted the exterior to be creepy AF and match the dark tone of the horror genre. As a result, Briarcliff Manor is actually the Old Santa Ana Courthouse in Santa Ana, California, rather than a historic hospital or mental institution. Its 19th-century style is Richardsonian and Romanesque, after the architect Henry Hobson Richardson.
The Death Chute
Despite taking creative liberties in Briarcliff Manor’s design and focusing on East Coast buildings, there is one aspect of the asylum that immediately brings Waverly Hills Sanatorium to mind: the death chute.
Worthington’s research into tuberculosis hospitals revealed tunnels used to discreetly remove the bodies of deceased patients. He describes Briarcliff’s death chute as “a weird, nasty tunnel that seems to go on forever…” much like that of Waverly Hills’ body chute, which is over 500 feet long and pretty fucking creepy.10
Let’s end on a quick macabre side note and acknowledge the fact that the body chute saved lives in 2022. About 100 tourists at the Waverly Hills Sanatorium took shelter in the body chute during a tornado warning. While some visitors weren’t happy campers, others took the opportunity to explore the whole tunnel.
For more posts about the historical inspirations behind American Horror Story, click here!
Footnotes
- Solvej Schou, “’American Horror Story: Asylum’: Inside Creepy Briarcliff Manor,” Entertainment Weekly, December 12, 2012. ↩︎
- Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace, Anonymous Sproutflix, 1972. ↩︎
- Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace. ↩︎
- E. Liu, “Willowbrook State School: Institutional Abuse, Medical Ethics and the Rise of Disability Rights in the United States,” Critical Debates in Humanities, Science and Global Justice 5, no. 2 (2025). ↩︎
- Alfred Maisel, “Bedlam 1946,” Life, May 6, 1946, 103. ↩︎
- Maisel, Bedlam 1946,” 102. ↩︎
- Katherine Anderson, Danvers State Hospital (Arcadia Publishing, 2018). ↩︎
- Schou, “’American Horror Story: Asylum.’” ↩︎
- Schou, “‘American Horror Story: Asylum.’” ↩︎
- Schou, “’American Horror Story: Asylum.’” ↩︎
Bibliography
*Several of the links below are Amazon affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
“About Us.” Waverly Hills Sanatorium. Accessed August 15, 2026.
Anderson, Katherine. Danvers State Hospital. Arcadia Publishing, 2018.
Costa, Albert B. “Waksman Discovers the Antibiotic Streptomycin.” EBSCO. Last modified 2021.
Liu, E. “Willowbrook State School: Institutional Abuse, Medical Ethics and the Rise of Disability Rights in the United States.” Critical Debates in Humanities, Science and Global Justice 5, no. 2 (2025): 85-102.
Maisel, Alfred. “Bedlam 1946.” Life, May 6, 1946, 102-18.
Schou, Solvej. “‘American Horror Story: Asylum’: Inside creepy Briarcliff Manor.” Entertainment Weekly, December 12, 2012.
Tkacz, Phil, Shawn Logan, Jay Gravatte, and Hope Bryant. “Waverly Hills Sanatorium.” Kentucky Historic Institutions. Accessed August 15, 2026.
Willowbrook: The Last Great Disgrace. Anonymous Sproutflix, 1972.
Further Reading
*Click on the covers for link.



Leave a Reply